Conservatory Roof ReplacementBarnsley

Most people start out thinking the choice is about looks. Once you have sat in a conservatory through a Barnsley winter and a hot July, it turns out to be about temperature, light and noise, and only then about what it looks like from the garden.

The second deciding factor is the structure already standing. Whatever sits on top leans on the walls, cill, door heads and base, so a roofer worth hiring inspects those before promising anything.

The three roofs side by side

General points that hold for most conservatories. Your own room, which way it faces and the products a firm uses will move each of them a little.

Comparison of tiled, glass and polycarbonate conservatory roofs
Living under itTilesGlazedPoly
DaylightDimmest of the three, short of a lantern or roof lightsBrightest, and stays clear for yearsBright when new, then clouds and yellows
A hot July afternoonFeels like any other roomFar kinder with solar-control unitsUsually the one you flee from
A cold January morningWarmest, insulated as a ceiling isFair, better with modern unitsColdest
Heavy rain overheadBarely heardA soft patterDrums loudly
Load on the frameMost, so have frame and footings looked atMiddlingLeast
Lifespan, broadlyLongest, close to a house roofLong, though seals need watchingShortest
Building controlNormally needs approvingNormally not, while it stays a conservatoryNormally not, while it stays a conservatory

The pattern is plain enough: the more the roof behaves like part of the house, the more it costs and the more paperwork it brings.

Tiles over insulation

Insulation sandwiched between lightweight tiles on top and a skimmed plaster ceiling below. Sit under one and the room reads as an extension, not a greenhouse.

In its favour

Year-round use. Winter heat stays in and the midsummer glare stays out.

Quiet. Rain on tiles barely registers inside.

Fits in. Tiles can be chosen to sit alongside the main roof, including slate-look finishes.

Against it

Less light. Expect a dimmer room unless roof lights or a lantern go in too.

Weight. The frame often needs strengthening, and the base and footings need checking.

Approval. It usually needs Building Regulations sign-off, which adds a fee and some time.

Sealed glass units

Sealed double-glazed panels replacing whatever is up there now. For anyone who bought the conservatory for the sky, this one keeps it.

In its favour

Light. Nothing beats it, and good glass stays clear for many years.

Better than it was. Modern units with solar-control and low-emissivity coatings (a thin layer that reflects heat) do far more than older glass.

Usually no approval. The room stays a conservatory, so the exemption normally still applies.

Against it

Still glass. It will never be as warm in January as an insulated ceiling.

Cleaning. Leaves and grime show from underneath, particularly under trees.

Twin-wall polycarbonate

Multi-wall plastic sheets fitted to the existing roof bars. Plenty of older conservatories still have it, and replacing like with like is the lowest-cost route.

In its favour

Lowest outlay. Often the quickest job of the three.

Lightest. It puts the least load on an older frame.

Against it

Comfort. Hot in summer, cold in winter, loud in rain.

Ageing. Sheets can discolour and go cloudy, so you may be doing this again sooner.

Will the frame cope?

Get this wrong and a tiled roof turns from a good idea into a costly one. Your frame went up expecting glazing or plastic overhead, not rafters, insulation and tiles.

LABC (Local Authority Building Control) lists what its inspectors examine on these jobs: the frames, the support above doors and the foundations, all judged against the heavier roof. A sensible surveyor runs through the same list before quoting:

  • The base and footings. Any cracking, sinking or a base laid straight on a patio is a warning sign.
  • The frame itself. Whether it is uPVC, aluminium or timber, and whether it has steel reinforcement inside.
  • Openings. Wide bifold or French doors need proper support above them once a heavy roof is on.

If any of that is doubtful, the answer may be a lighter roof, or a bit of extra work underneath before the tiled roof goes ahead. You can read LABC's own note on solid roofs on conservatories.

Which roof suits which Barnsley home?

Victorian stone and slate

In the older streets near the centre, where black-weathered sandstone sits under Welsh slate, a solid roof in a dark slate-look tile tends to look the most at home. Check the conservation area position first; the Barnsley rules page covers it.

Hillside gardens

Where the garden falls away and the conservatory catches wind and sun, comfort matters more than usual. A tiled roof, or glass with good solar control, is likely to make more difference than new polycarbonate.

A small room you mainly pass through

If the conservatory is really a back porch or a utility space, new polycarbonate or glass may be all you need, and you skip the weight questions entirely.

None of this is a rule. Two houses on the same street can need different roofs because one faces south and the other sits in the shade.

Still torn between roofs?

Someone stood in the room with a tape measure will answer it faster than any chart. We can find you a roofer who covers your part of the borough.

Send this and we go looking for a roof firm working in your corner of Barnsley, then tell you their name. They only get your details after you say yes, and there is no charge to you. How we match you

Where and who
Get a quote